The World in Winter
(original title The Long Winter)
by Sam Youd, writing as John Christopher.
Introduction by Hari Kunzru.
Penguin Worlds,
Penguin Books, 2016 (1962).
‘Put fire in their hands and they will not be afraid. They will carry their sun with them even here.’
‘The sun brings life,’ he said, ‘not death.’
Pt 3, 5
In the 1960s it was believed that we were due to a return to a Little Ice Age, an interglacial cooling such as those beginning around 1650, 1770 and 1850, each separated from the next by a warmer interval. Triggers suggested for this cooling included volcanic activity, changes in oceanic circulation, alterations in orbit or the tilt of the earth’s axis, reductions in human populations from war or disease, and cyclical decreases in solar irradiation or insolation.
In The World in Winter (first published in 1962 as The Long Winter) the author plumps for the final explanation as the cause of the so-called Fratellini winter, a rapid and drastic climatic change which sees much of the northern hemisphere above 35° latitude disabled by snow and ice packs in the sea, including Britain where the novel starts.
Here is where we meet Andrew Leedon, a television documentary maker, and through his eyes we view radical changes not only in living conditions but also in geopolitics, society at large and personal relationships. Ultimately where will loyalties lie – if, that is, one manages to survive?
It feels strange to be contemplating a postulated world in winter amidst our current climate crisis with rising temperatures and burning forests, especially when even six decades ago the immanent reality of global warming was well understood; but it suits a novel of many ambiguities for the reader to consider what-ifs in which situations are turned on their heads. What if, for example, a late centre of Empire like Britain were to find roles reversed and former colonies like Nigeria became the destination of economic migrants fleeing a distant island in turmoil? How would those refugees from a moribund country expect to be treated?
Andrew becomes one of those displaced people. His wife Carol has left him for a close though influential friend David; his job in television disappears when blizzards render most power-reliant technologies irrelevant; arriving in Lagos with David’s estranged wife Madeleine his status as a European lacking funds renders him a persona non grata as far as employment and accommodation are concerned.
Will an act of kindness in the past change his and Madeleine’s prospects in Nigeria? And if offered would he welcome a chance to return to the arctic wasteland of his former home to seek something he had lost?
Sharing features seen in John Wyndham’s apocalyptic novels from the 1950s (such as The Day of the Triffids and The Kraken Wakes) The World in Winter is part of a genre that writer Brian Aldiss once dismissed as ‘catastrophe cosy’ – that is, they usually featured a lone white hero, almost invariably British, who somehow managed to survive a fairly plausible global catastrophe, despite all the odds, salvaging hope for an improving future by means of sheer guts and intelligence. This novel fits that blueprint, it’s true, but though in this respect it’s a book of its time – as Hari Kunzru’s excellent introduction to this edition points out – it also tackles issues of race and ethnicity with a degree of sensitivity as well as acuity, even if it ends with a sense of division and resignation, reflecting contemporary attitudes.
The narrative is very much focused on a quintet of characters, although we come across a fair few incidental players. Andrew comes across as sympathetic though we may not always like or agree with his actions, and we quite soon sense his friend David – his only British friend? – is not someone in whom to place implicit trust. As for the women in Andrew’s life, Carol and Maddie, they seemed a little opaque to me, and I wasn’t entirely convinced about their sudden abandonments of their men.
It was the Nigerian, Abonitu, who most impressed me: he was principally motivated by honesty, gratitude and friendship, but he was also pragmatic, brave and prone to give certain individuals the benefit of the doubt, not always to his benefit. But he was always aware of a general tendency towards ‘othering’ people of a different ethnicity, culture or skin colour, and doubting their loyalty according to those criteria, especially when, during a Nigerian expedition to ice-bound Britain, Andrew suggests that equatorial Africans might behave as white colonialists did in Africa: “The sun brings life, not death,” Andrew pointedly says, expressing his sublimated fears.
‘Catastrophe cosy’ or not, The World in Winter is an engrossing read with much to say about colonialism, prejudice and loyalty, all set at a period of transition. As well as implicitly referencing the period it was written in – end of Empire, immigration from former colonies – it has continued relevance sixty-plus years on when geopolitical and climatic crises are resulting in population stresses not just in Britain, of course, but around the world.
Read for the #1962Club and, as it’s a bit of a thriller, for #RIPxviii
How fascinating and relevant indeed! I think we’re seeing many situations turned on their heads, even if in a different way than posited in this book. Reading is always a good way to practice considering different possibilities.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I couldn’t agree more with your comment about reading, Lory. I saw this interesting comment on social media today from author SF Said, which I thought related:
What factor has the biggest impact on children’s life chances? Socio-economic background, or how well they do in tests? Nope: it’s READING FOR PLEASURE. Kids who read because they enjoy it do better in every way than kids who don’t. There is nothing more important.
The kind of mental resilience that reading can bring helps strengthen imaginative thinking, compassion and empathy, all of which allow the individual to see valid alternatives to what is often assumed to be the only right way to think; reading can also explore the consequences of acting in certain ways and get the reader to weigh up the range of choices they might face. (But here I am spouting a homily which you’re already familiar with! Sorry.)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder why some kids enjoy reading and others don’t? That would be interesting to explore.
Just read Terry Pratchett’s biography in which he suddenly caught on to reading after being a non-reader, inspired by The Wind in the Willows and his local library … it’s a lovely example.
LikeLiked by 1 person
With some kids it could be ADHD and an inability to sit still, or dyslexia and a genuine difficulty with interpreting the signs on the page. Though, having said this, our son was only finally diagnosed with the latter at uni, and has since read avidly.
I’d love to read that biography, but I see there’s also a final collection of unpublished short stories just issued. Still, what a lovely anecdote about ‘catching’ the bug of reading. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
A very interesting switch on the way we are viewing our path to catastrophe at the moment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, it very much feels as if we’ve passed the point of no return, even if it’s not in the manner the author envisioned here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
And on the SF side, I recommend Lucifer’s Hammer – Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle – a post-apocalyptic world caused by a comet, which explores what’s left. From 1977, before the genre became saturated.
And On The Beach, Nevil Shute, another groundbreaking story, 1957, by a British author who emigrated to Australia – about the effect of a nuclear war.
They stick with you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve read a couple of Niven and Pournelle’s collaborative efforts but not this. And I watched the movie version of the Shute on television many decades ago but not read the novel it was based on
LikeLike
John Christopher never wrote a book with a happy ending if he could help it. His Tripod Trilogy ends with clouds on the horizon and his Sword of the Spirits trilogy was downright depressing. And those were his middlegrade books. I can only imagine how he let his pessimism show in his adult novels.
Had you read much of his stuff before?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I’ve read a few of his titles, whether as John Christopher or as Sam Youd – the first only of the Tripods trilogy, a couple of his more ‘literary’ novels and also The Possessors and The Death of Grass. My reviews should all be available via the Sam Youd tag or this link: https://calmgrove.wordpress.com/tag/sam-youd/
I know what you mean by that particular pessimism – may, knowing what we do now, he was right to be so?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the link.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My pleasure. 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not a book or writer I’ve come across, Chris. I’ve made a note to seek it out, though, as your review makes it sound like something I’d enjoy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
‘Enjoy’ is a relative term, Jan, isn’t it! I certainly admired the writing and the worldbuilding but I found the scenarios he posited distinctly uncomfortable reading. Worth exploring though!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is indeed a relative term. I flipflop between enjoy and appreciate, and as shorthand neither word exactly captures what I want to say, which is usually ‘be stimulated/provoked/educated/taken out of my comfort zone/entertained/diverted by’.
LikeLiked by 1 person
If only there was a all-encompassing term to describe that engagement, a transitive verb – I shall have to mull that over!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Totally fascinated by the introduction of Nigerian characters here—it seems like an unusually global outlook for a cosy catastrophe (though, to be fair, my primary experience of those is The Day of the Triffids, and maybe Fred Hoyle’s The Black Cloud counts too). I haven’t yet read any John Christopher but he’s clearly worth seeking out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have read the Hoyle in yonks, Elle, though I’m slightly trepident about revisiting classic SF I once admired! (I’ve actually got the Wyndham lined up for a reread next month.)
Under his own name of Sam Youd JC also wrote more conventional (?) novels, of which I’ve so far enjoyed A Palace of Strangers and The Winter Swan; yet perhaps ‘conventional’ isn’t the right word – the latter is related by a deceased person and the former is about mixed ethnic heritage, rather on a par with seeing situations from a Nigerian point of view.
LikeLike
The Hoyle honestly isn’t very good. The Wyndham is, though. And thanks for the head’s up on Sam Youd/JC’s other work!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Many of his titles are being reissued by his family under the imprint The SYLE Press (the initials stand for Sam Youd Literary Estate). Fantastic listings are there to explore on https://thesylepress.com/ if you’re interested.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I must read more John Christopher – this sounds great. I’ve been obsessed with his children’s book The Lotus Caves since I was a kid. This sounds slightly more cheerful than The Death of Grass??
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, Laura, more cheerful towards the end than The Death of Grass, though that’s not saying much! I haven’t got round to The Lotus Caves yet, but who knows, it might be sooner rather than later – or not at all, given the state of my TBR.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds most interesting, Chris – even if the climate catastrophe is different to the one we currently face, it’s still relevant. And the exploration of the colonial element is intriguing too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Worth you (or Mr K?) trying out if it ever crosses your path, Karen!
LikeLiked by 1 person
What an interesting insight into a book I do not know. Thanks, Chris, your reviews often whet my appetite and encourage me to broaden my reading range. I’ve made a note of this one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re welcome, Anne, I too like to have my reading range broadened, or else I mostly stick with a limited range of genres. Anyway, hope you finally get to try this, it’s certainly thought-provoking!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Funnily enough I was thinking of this novel for Sci-Fi month when I was perusing my shelves yesterday.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Would love to see your take on it if you choose to read it for SciFi Month, Annabel. 🙂
LikeLike
An interesting genre and pick—I wasn’t aware of these (only the more recent climate fiction), but as Karen also says below, irrespective of the form, the book seems certainly very relevant in the present. And as you point out, this does go beyond simply the hero saving the day trope into race and ethnicity which are ever relevant no matter how much time passes. Glad you picked this one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Considering this was written more than 60 years ago it’s quite forward-looking in terms of attitudes and prejudices as well as in predicting just how radical changes would be after a sudden global crisis.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds like a really interesting read! I’m in the middle of two ice-age books at the moment – “Shaman” by Kim Stanley Robinson and “Shelters of Stone” by Jean M Auel (last but one in the Earth’s children series). Both are set near the end of the last ice age at about 10,000 BCE.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve heard of but never tried these two authors, Jo, so if you’re enjoying these two books I’ll bear them in mind.
LikeLike
I found The World in Winter interesting, but also unsettling. I feel you gleaned a lot more from the text than I did and I admire how well you’ve expressed your thoughts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is unsettling, Mayri, I agree, including the protagonist’s final actions which wrongfooted me somewhat. But I knew from past experience that John Christopher often confounds expectations!
LikeLiked by 1 person
A tricksy author! 🤔
LikeLiked by 1 person
😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
A thoughtful review, Chris.
As regards pessimism (what he also referred to as his bleak view of humanity), Sam Youd was well aware of that tendency in some of his writings.
In that respect, The World in Winter could be said to have had a lucky escape. The original ending was considered by his editor to be too miserable, and he was persuaded to tone it up. More of that in the Afternote to our edition.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Nick, and I always think it’s important to have some pessimism as an option in literature, these days as much as before, if not more. As the SYLE Press edition of The World in Winter is the only one currently in print, I’m sure interested readers will get to that informative Afternote whenever they decide to read this early example of cli-fi: https://thesylepress.com/bookshop/
LikeLike