Creepily insistent

© C A Lovegrove

‘The Dunwich Horror’ by H P Lovecraft,
in The Dunwich Horror and Other Stories.
Arcturus Books, 2022 (1929).

Published in 1929 when the author was nearly 40, this 1928 novella represents Lovecraft in his fully-fledged antiquarian horror mode, set in one of his preferred New England locales and in the university town of Arkham, Massachusetts. Sparsely settled as parts of Essex County were in the early 20th century, folks there kept pretty much to themselves, leading to some families becoming inbred. And then there’s this one branch of the Whateleys, consisting of the decidedly strange and reclusive Lavinia, her eccentric father known as Wizard Whateley, and her very strange infant Wilbur, father unknown.

The nearby settlement of Dunwich is spooked by odd lights and disturbing rumblings in and around Sentinel Hill, and by the strange foetid smells that emanate from the Whateley homestead. Still, Wizard Whateley pays out good gold for the succession of cattle that are led to the farm though, curiously, the herd never gets any larger.

But when building works at the farm change the house’s internal layout it rouses more than their mild interest, as does the rapid growth and precocious behaviour of young Wilbur, who shares his grandfather’s predilection for ancient arcane knowledge. That predilection leads Wilbur to consult old tomes in centres of academic excellence – including Arkham – but unfortunately his last visit to Arkham triggers a series of incidents soon known as the Dunwich Horror.

Sketch of Arkham’s street plan, by H P Lovecraft, showing Miskatonic University

Those new to Lovecraft’s literary style may baulk at the first few pages, with its accumulation of adjectives and adverbs designed to set an atmosphere warning of horror to come: gorges and ravines of problematical depth … raucous, creepily insistent rhythms of stridently piping bullfrogs ... rotting gimbrel roofsthe broken-steepled church harbors the one slovenly mercantile establishment. But luckily the narrative proper soon gets going and we start to get a better understanding of why Dunwich and surrounds deserved its reputation as a place to be shunned.

Over the years since Wilbur’s birth in 1913 his atypical physical development has not only attracted notice locally but also further afield, as when for example he visits Dr Armitage, Miskatonic University’s librarian, and Armitage’s colleagues Professor Rice and Dr Morgan. The obscure and sinister volumes that Wilbur consults, and later the seemingly indecipherable notebooks he leaves behind, all provide clues to the secrets that the Whateleys have been concealing in their isolated home. Will the academics be able to deal with what they surmise is the extra-dimensional menace that emerges as the autumnal equinox of 1928 approaches?

This long short story, virtually a novelette, is regarded by aficionados as a key text in his Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos, introducing Massachusetts – particularly the Miskatonic river and, on its banks, the town of Arkham – as a nexus of latent horror and the scene of around a dozen of the author’s tales.

As a narrative The Dunwich Horror is more satisfying than many of Lovecraft’s works which I’ve read over the years: rather than the climax of the action being the final denouement (often when the terrified protagonist comes rudely face to face with the nameless but expected horror) there is instead a satisfying resolution as well as a final explanatory revelation.

This was surprisingly more of a pleasure to read than I was expecting from past experience. But then I am now a lot older, much less dismissive and, hopefully, a bit more appreciative of such pulp fiction than was my wont. Now if only those creepily insistent bull-frogs and, especially, whippoorwills could give it a rest…

Read for the #1929Club. Other 1929 titles reviewed here include Virginia Woolf’s A Room of One’s Own, the English translation of Hermann Hesse’s Steppenwolf, and Erich Kästner’s Emil and the Detectives ...

also as a final celebration of this year’s Readers Imbibing Peril #RIPxvii

#RIPxvii: books on mystery, suspense, thriller, horror, dark fantasy, supernatural, and Gothic

Advance notice: Witch Week is imminent! The schedule appears 30th October, with the first post due on All Hallows Eve.


8 thoughts on “Creepily insistent

  1. An interesting choice, Chris! I’ve only read one Lovecraft which I really enjoyed and which was surprisingly spooky, though I think my Eldest Child has read more of him. Perhaps some shorter works would be a good way to explore him further…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wonder which HPL novel that was that you enjoyed, Karen, perhaps At the Mountains of Madness?

      In my “archive” (aka shelves of neglected volumes) I have a collection of essays and spoof studies called The Necronomicon; it includes a learned piece by Angela Carter, so if she gave Lovecraft’s work more than a passing glance who am I to sneer at my youthful obsession with such eldritch lore? I must dig this out and give it my renewed attention…


  2. Pingback: Creepily insistent – Glyn Hnutu-healh: History, Alchemy, and Me

  3. This was one of the first Lovecraft stories I read and at the time I wasn’t at all sure whether I liked or hated his style – I’ve since come to love all those adjectives. My comment at the time was that this was my favourite in the collection that I had read it in, and those whippoorwills got special mention!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. An accumulation of adjectives, yes, that’s his trademark, isn’t it! This story seems to be a favourite of many Lovecraft fans.

      Incidentally, I had no idea what those whippoorwills were – I’d assumed they were either fantastic birds HPL had invented, or possibly hoopoes – but I now see they are nightjars which overwinter in Central America.

      Audio recordings of their repeated shrieky calls are truly weird, the “whip-poor-will” motif going from B flat above middle C to G and then up an octave, over and over again; en masse and at length it would certainly drive me mad, creepily insistent for sure! I can see why HPL brought them into this story.

      Liked by 1 person

Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.