The price of having

Maesglase by Velela, CC BY-SA 2.5 via Wikimedia Commons

The Life of Rebecca Jones: A Novel
(originally O! Tyn y Gorchudd)
by Angharad Price,
translated by Lloyd Jones,
afterword by Jane Aaron.
MacLehose Press 2014 (2002)

I was given a long life. It has spanned the whole of the twentieth century and has been full of experience. I have felt the rough fist of misfortune and the soft palm of joy. I have spent many hours in darkness. Yet light came anew. I learned that the price of having is losing.

The life of upland farming communities has never been an easy one. In southern Snowdonia one such farmstead has survived a millennium on the flanks of Maesglase mountain between Dolgellau and Dinas Mawddwy, but one may wonder for how much longer, especially with the rapid changes wrought from the 20th century onwards into the present.

The Life of Rebecca Jones recounts the deeds and experiences of the Jones family from Tynybraich farm over the course of that century, told as by Rebecca herself. Only, this being a nonfiction novel, it’s actually told by Angharad Price, Rebecca’s great-niece, and so could be called a recreated autobiography or memoir. That doesn’t detract from its utter authenticity though, nor from its poetic power nor its emotional impact.

For this is a novel about continuity; or rather continuance, when a lack of disconnection or interruption cannot be taken for granted. “Continuance is painful,” Rebecca tells us. “It is the cross onto which we are tied: its beams pulling us this way and that. A longing for continuance lies at the heart of our nature.” And yet, “we are born to die. And we spend our lives coming to terms with that paradox.”

Maesglase waterfall by Velela, CC BY-SA 2.5 via Wikimedia Commons

This is a beautiful heartful novel which deserves its plaudits. Among other things, in focusing on one valley — Cwm Maesglasau — it allows the reader to observe the regular patterns of the year as seasons come and go: the daily life at the farm, the wonders of nature, the familial customs that formed the bedrock of rural communities. But we also see that such patterns of living were not universal because the Jones family had to cope with unforeseen vicissitudes: three of Rebecca’s brothers were afflicted with blindness. The repercussions of this were that all three went off at an early age to Worcester College, established for “the blind sons of gentlemen”; and in later life a BBC documentary in the 1960s was to feature their remarkable story.

The original title of this novel was O! Tyn y Gorchudd which could be roughly translated from Welsh as “Oh, pull aside the veil.” The author’s choice of this title was taken from a hymn written in the 18th century by one of the family’s ancestors, Hugh Jones, in which the mist which often masks Maesglasau mountain symbolises the veil that can hide the sinner from the figure on the cross, and the stream that tumbles down a spectacular waterfall through the cwm represents the blood that cleanses away sins. But of course the phrase can also refer to the veil that hid the world from the brothers’ sight, just as Tyn y Gorgudd could, coincidentally, be translated as The House of the Veil; after all the farmhouse was called Tynybraich, meaning the house on a spur of land.

However, in the television documentary the women of the farm were largely unseen and this, I think, is one of the veils that Angharad Price was concerned about drawing back: Rebecca herself, and her mother, her paternal grandmother, her sisters-in-law, her nieces. In rural life women were expected to play supportive but secondary roles yet they were crucial lynchpins, for without them traditional farming just wouldn’t continue. Another veil that the author wanted to pull aside was the pace of change and the effect the outside world has had and continues to have on isolated communities. Already it was happening in the last century, especially following the Great War, then as communications and technology and the invasion of English culture proceeded apace the world Rebecca knew at the start of the century was unrecognisable at the end. Even the ancient farmhouse was demolished and replaced.

But not everything changed so obviously. The valley, the mountains, the stream, remain as before and the flowers, the sheep and the birds of prey are still in evidence. The prose poetry of old Hugh Jones which peppers the pages witnesses to nature’s hold on Maesglasau, even if traffic on the A470 may now thunder past on the way to or from Dolgellau and beyond. And Hugh Jones’ poetry is matched, even in this sensitive translation into English by novelist Lloyd Jones, by Angharad Price’s priceless prose quietly telling the passing of years. The text may be at times sparse, almost matter-of-fact and shorn of any unnecessary adjectives or adverbs, but emotions, though held in check, remain raw, and the way words are used is telling.

If we imagine The Life of Rebecca Jones flowing like the Nant Maeglasau, there will be a parting of the mist in the final sentences that will reveal why it’s important that the life of women like Rebecca is told. And if, as she says, the “price of having” is indeed losing, we will understand that loss can manifest in many forms and that we have to be prepared to pay the price. I feel extremely privileged to have read this deeply affecting novel, as you may have guessed; it paints a portrait of a close-knit way of life that is slowly unravelling.


A rendition of Hugh Jones’s hymn O! Tyn y Gorchudd by a Welsh chapel choir, starting at 0:32

A work read for Dewithon, the Wales Readathon, on St David’s Day

19 thoughts on “The price of having

  1. I know that A470 road a little, from visiting Harlech regularly at one time, and remember some beautiful glimpses of the views. Somehow, we always promised to stop an explore on another occasion.

    I’ve just ordered the novel from our library, and made a note that next time circumstances allow us to visit North Wales Maesglasau should be our destination.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. We’ve travelled up the A470 a couple of times too, and it’s odd to think that a place like Maesglasau (or Maesglase in today’s more usual spelling, though I think it’s pronounced the same) may well have been relatively isolated in the days when motor traffic was a rarity. Hope you enjoy this, Cath, while I wish I’d read this sooner (I’ve had it by the bed for a few months now) I also think I appreciate it more now.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Wales Readathon 2021 – Book Jotter

  3. This sounds wonderful. A few years ago I read Marie-Elsa Bragg’s book about Lake District hill farming, Towards Mellbreak. The Life of Rebecca Jones sounds similar.

    I love this part of Wales. My childhood holidays were almost all spent in Fairbourne on the Mawddach estuary, so I know Dolgellau fairly well. I went to university in Aberystwyth, too, but we always took the A487 at Cross Foxes to get there via Corris and Machynlleth. It’s been too long since I’ve visited (we scattered my mother’s ashes at the foot of Cader Idris on my last trip). Your review makes me want to go back. Thank you.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m glad this awoke some good memories, Jan; this is not an area of Wales I know well, generally passing through on my way north and back south on past occasions. Having lived in the Preseli Hills aspects of this Welsh-speaking farming community felt very familiar to me; looking out now at the Black Mountains helps me picture the Snowdonia landscape of the novel.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. This sounds really wonderful! (In fact, so good that I have to add it to my list – Wordery are now sending me a copy!) I read the beginning via a preview and it really “strikes a chord”.

    For two years when I was 4 and 5 years old my family would spend August on a farm in the hills near Rhosgadfan in North Wales. My parents would go off walking and my sister and I would help the farmer’s eldest son, Peter, around the farm. It was like having a window on another life. I loved it, (apart from the geese who I thought probably wanted to kill me).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, do let me know what you think of it when you’ve finished it, Jo! Your childhood holiday sounded like it was just what was needed to make it memorable and fun, geese notwithstanding (not to mention their poo!).

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Chris, this does indeed sound wonderful. And an ideal accompaniment to the book I’m reading for Dewithon – The Seasoning – which is a fictional account looking back at one woman’s life and the welsh neighbours which populate it. I would guess it may not be your type of book so I’m not recommending it per se but I’ve downloaded Rebecca Jones as a follow-on read 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It is wonderful, Sandra, with a real emotional gut punch towards the end to, as it were, seal its worth. In common with many of us I tend to know what I like, and to like what I know, but occasionally I do make forays out of my comfort zone so I’ll bear The Seasoning in mind, thanks! I’d be interested to hear your thoughts on the Rebecca Jones book.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Winding Up the Week #160 – Book Jotter

  7. Pingback: The Life of Rebecca Jones – What I Think About When I Think About Reading

Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.