Honest and very human

Edith Bland (née Nesbit) at work

The Magic World by E Nesbit,
Puffin Classics 1994 (1912)

Not everyone is successful at writing literary fairytales, especially those stories that mix the modern world with traditional wonder tales of magic and enchantment. Joan Aiken was one who mastered this deft conjoining of old and new, as did her predecessor Edith Nesbit. Maybe it takes a special individual, or maybe it requires a female touch — many 19th-century male writers, such as the Brothers Grimm, Charles Kingsley et al, found it hard not to come over all didactic and moral, though some female writers were not averse to these failings. Nesbit slyly parodies these aspects of Victorian literary fairytales at the end of “The Mixed Mine” when she concludes

“There is no moral to this story, except… But no – there is no moral.”

And yet morality lies deeply embedded in most of these dozen stories — the wicked meet their just deserts, or maybe just don’t profit from their wickedness; the meek inherit the earth, or at least don’t lose out. She subverts your expectations, but in a nice way, leaving the reader challenged but also satisfied.

As was the way with much fiction then the stories were published in magazines first before appearing in book form in 1912; pretty much all Nesbit’s output appeared this way, even the novels like Five Children and It (which betrays its origins with uniform-length episodic chapters, loosely linked). With the twelve tales of The Magic World there was of course no need to have a narrative thread and yet a few of the pieces have themes in common, and one or two even explicitly reference another in the collection. I’ll be grouping some of these tales according to their commonalty rather than dealing with them in the order they’re here published.

Some of the tales involve transformations, with the protagonist taking the form of some creature or other. In “The Cat-hood of Maurice” the titular boy somehow becomes the family cat, and learns what it feels like to be teased intolerably — a case of the punishment suiting the crime. However, in “Kenneth and the Carp” Kenneth is falsely accused of theft but when he becomes the aforementioned carp he is able to prove his innocence. (Incidentally, this story is set in an historic moated house similar in all respects to one that Nesbit herself lived in.) In one of the few tales eschewing overt magic, “The Related Muff”, cousin Sidney is wrongly regarded as a ‘muff’ — an incompetent who ‘muffs’ everything he attempts — until an emergency demonstrates his ability to rise to the occasion, a transformation of sorts. (The narrator sometimes talks of himself in the third person, a literary tic that Nesbit had previously used in The Wouldbegoods.)

Sometimes something else transforms. In “The White Cat” Octavius finds a forgotten china ornament in the form of a cat which comes to life and reveals family secrets and changes fortunes. A spyglass which magically changes the magnitude of objects transforms the lives and fortunes of Augustus and his newfound friend Edward in “The Mixed Mine”. In “Accidental Magic” young Quentin follows the lead of many a fairytale hero by falling asleep on a ancient relic (in this case the Altar Stone at Stonehenge), which transforms into a ship en route to Atlantis; Nesbit here revisited themes she’d explored in The Story of the Amulet.

More reminiscent of traditional fairytales and fairytale motifs are the remaining half dozen pieces, often featuring princesses, princes, magicians and mythical creatures. Some involve the laying of curses and their subsequent circumvention. In “The Princess and the Hedge-pig” — the latter an alternative name for a hedgehog — a king and queen try to stop Princess Ozyliza being cursed at her christening by a wicked fairy’s curse, to no avail. A prince and a princess are also afflicted with curses in “Belinda and Bellamant” but luckily bells (the pair’s names suggest an affinity with these instruments) furnish a solution to their problems. The enchanter who is implicated in the workings of this last story also appears, along with Princess Belinda, in “The Magician’s Heart”; here more curses fly through the air at a royal christening. The motif of magician’s power lying in an external object is revisited in “Septimus Septimusson”; the hero — whose name denotes the seventh son of a seventh son who traditionally has exceptional abilities — has to seek his fortune, encountering that object during the course of his adventures.

Surprisingly, not that many young females feature as protagonists. In “Justnowland” Elsie’s adventures are reminiscent of those of Gulliver or Rabelais’ Gargantua and Pantagruel in that we have talking crows and dragons, but her kind nature wins the day. Finally in “The Aunt and Amabel” Anabel actually enters a wardrobe to access a magic world, rather like Lucy in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, leading to suggestions that C S Lewis subconsciously borrowed this idea from Nesbit.

Edith Nesbit

So much for superficialities; Nesbit’s stories are so much more than this. There is humour and mischievousness in them, truths and profundities, playfulness and seriousness, ingenuousness and knowingness. They are more than just fairytales but follow in that great tradition; they partake of the Edwardian period (what with the presence of a Quentin and an Augustus and a Maurice) even while the whiff of Grimm and Anderson wafts in their wake. Here is a collection that I’m happy to keep on my shelves alongside compendiums of traditional tales from the British Isles, Turkey, Russia and elsewhere — that’s how much I esteem them — because they are honest and, essentially, very human.


Repost of review first published 20th July 2015

28 thoughts on “Honest and very human

  1. Pat

    I just discovered your blog and I can see I’m going to be in trouble here. I have so many books! And an entire library on my Kindle. It’s paradise!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. When one sees how many good stories one has missed in the past, there comes a feeling that one might as well stop scribbling and leave it to the older gems. But then, at least we can include tablets and emails and things to relate to the modern readership …

    Liked by 1 person

    1. No, no, never get discouraged from scribbling just because past writers did it so exquisitely! Potentially we can all bring our own unique viewpoints to apparently hackneyed plots andy storylines and by using our own voices to narrate refresh them utterly. And past writers are never so perfect that one can’t critique them and avoid infelicities they may have in their writing in one’s own scribbles. Take heart, Col, take heart!


      1. Actually, it would be interesting to find out whether from the depth of your fantasy/quest reading experience you would be able to find a parallel for my latest – aspects, perhaps, but I am encouraged by the fact that I cannot think of anything approximating the same sort of mix having appeared before!

        Liked by 1 person

        1. If you want to separately send me a story breakdown or synopsis I’d be happy to comment on your latest from the depths of my shallow reading experience, Col. I’ve emailed you separately …


  3. Thank you for this very interesting review. I have always loved the E. Nesbit novels (read them myself as a child and then to my son), but don’t think I’ve read these stories. Will look them up. They sound rather like the feminist “fractured fairytales” that were popular in the 1980s and 1990s. She was ahead of her time in so many ways. I like the photo of her too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I was pleased to have found a secondhand copy of this collection, Josna, as I’ve never seen it offered new in bookshops. If you’ve a Kindle you can probably get it for free, but I prefer a dead tree copy. It’s true that Nesbit often gently subverts the genre in a way similar to those more modern ‘fractured’ versions; but despite occasional phrases and questionable attitudes which reflect her times (and I can’t be sure how much she’s sending up those attitudes) her stories stand up tolerably well for a modern audience.

      Yes, the photo seems to illustrate her bohemian approach — I’ve never seen a formal picture of her and can’t imagine her in a frightful Victorian bonnet (if she ever wore one).

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: Literally challenged: update | calmgrove

  5. I remember how wonderful it was to find this collection when I was devouring Nesbit (somewhat late — I think I actually discovered her in my early teens). I would love to own a copy but have not found one yet. Thanks for the appreciation that illuminates so much of what makes her a special and still highly readable writer.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks very much, Lory! I was lucky to find this Puffin 1994 paperback in a charity shop, and you might be able to locate a copy online. She was such an interesting person n her own right, and I’m glad her fiction reflects her mould-breaking lifestyle.


      1. I will keep looking! Fortunately I do have the selection by Naomi Lewis, “E. Nesbit Fairy Stories” which includes many of the best stories from various collections. And I recommend Nesbit’s memoir, “Long Ago When I Was Young” if you haven’t read it already — I found a lovely edition illustrated by Edward Ardizzone when I was in England years ago.

        Liked by 1 person

    1. She is indeed. And maybe I’ll even get to read some of her adult stories before the end of the year, especially her ghost stories (which I promise myself I will do every year but have singularly failed to do). 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Interestingly, though better known as writers of children’s fiction both Nesbit and Aiken were dab hands at spooky tales ideal for autumn onwards! Nesbit’s are in modern editions under titles variously ‘Tales of Terror’ and ‘In the Dark’, while Aiken’s collections include A Bundle of Nerves and A Touch of Chill… Hallowe’en’s coming up, of course. 🙂


  6. When I was a kid this was one of my favorite Nesbit books, of which we had quite a few (we may well have been the only kids in town who did!), but I didn’t always get when she was talking about real things. Since I’d never heard of Stonehenge, it was a long time before I figured out where Quentin was, and I think it was the ‘Justnowland’ story that featured a book with an enigmatic cloth cover, embroidered with ABC.

    One thing I always really enjoy about Nesbit stories is the way she pokes fun at the didactic habits of the time, and how her characters are ordinary children who get into trouble or need to be taught a lesson about teasing the cat.

    My other favorite was The Little Bookroom. No wonder I ended up liking Aiken and Jones!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I have a hardback copy of this now, Jean, and it’s one I want to return to again and again (just like the Farjeon book). Nesbit’s collection and its impact reminded me of the advice given to imbibe “fairy tales and more fairy tales”. Usually attributed to Einstein, the quote exists in various permutations (examined in this scholarly article https://blogs.loc.gov/folklife/2013/12/einsteins-folklore/) but originating around 1958 when foaflore suggests he thought such narratives crucial to the development of scientific thinking.

      That’s as may be, but fairytales — usually in some literary form — also reflect human values and aspirations, don’t they, and Nesbit recognised that, I think. “But there is no moral” is her being explicit that didacticism should have no place in fairytales, that the listener or reader should draw their own lessons from the story — if indeed there are any lessons to learn.

      That Nesbit–Farjeon–Aiken–Jones chain is a thing of wonder and a joy to know, I agree, especially when more mature readings reveal further layers of meaning!


Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.