Square pegs

WordPress Free Photo Library

Louis Sachar: Holes
Bloomsbury 2000 (1998)

This immensely readable YA novel is a delight: it presents like real-life contemporary fiction but is littered with almost impossible coincidences; it feels like a piece of fantasy at times but is unrelenting in its portrayal of societal realities; it’s peopled by individuals who one moment may be stereotypical and the next become complex and unpredictable.

Stanley Yelnats has been accused and convicted of a crime he didn’t commit. His sentence is to go to Camp Green Lake, a correctional institute where boys are expected to dig regulation-sized holes to build good character.

And yet all is not as it seems: we are already alerted to the fact that Stanley didn’t commit a crime, that — suspiciously — his name is palindromic, that the institute is neither green nor by a lake, and that everyone there is a metaphorical square peg who will never fit the round hole they’re expected to dig.

Why do we really dig holes? To grow food — to find water — to discover treasure. What can we use a digging implement for? To dig, obviously, but also to measure, perhaps to maim, maybe as a support. And why do we write stories? To entertain, yes, but also to explore, to reveal, to inform. And because we’re human.

Holes is in fact a fairytale about being human, and about showing humanity. Stanley has to battle ogres and dragons and achieve impossible tasks (that is, warders, poisonous lizards, and crossing a desert without water) but he is as nothing unless he shows compassion, laced with a generous dollop of pragmatism. The novel has several layers, like the onions that feature in the plot, but like the peaches that also figure here it has sweetness to mitigate the sharp taste and a stone at the centre to represent essential truths.

And of course nobody is known by their true names: for a start, Stanley is called Caveman; his fellow detainees have nicknames like X-ray, Armpit, Zigzag, Magnet and Zero, masks to both conceal and reveal who they really are.

Sacher writes convincingly of harsh penal conditions, bullying, mind games, desert hazards and the mind-numbing tedium of repetitive back-breaking work; this all feels very realistic. At other times there is an epic quality to the narrative, with black humour occasionally breaking the bleakness; at one sttage King Solomon’s Mines might suggest itself, another a biblical spell in the wilderness, or a touch of magic realism where weather is concerned.

Sacher’s novel also has an archetypal quality about it, though it wears it lightly: the chapters are short yet more-ish, the characters familiar yet surprising, the coincidences incredible yet easy to accept. There are backstories introduced in a matter-of-fact way but at just the right point take us forward.

I enjoyed Holes very much, its cinematic quality so easy to transfer to the big screen that Disney not unexpectedly filmed it, with the screenplay by the author himself. But nothing beats reading — especially when the story’s resolution largely depends on a formerly illiterate character having learnt to read.

14 thoughts on “Square pegs

  1. I read this maybe ten years ago, when I was going for a job as a school librarian (didn’t get it sadly). The best YA speaks on different levels to different ages, and this is one such wonderful example that is as rewarding a read for adults as older children. Lovely review.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks so much, Annabel, I did find it hard to not say too much about this in the way of spoilers so I just resorted to superlatives. I’m ashamed to say I’d not heard of this novel before I picked it up a month or so back.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. I have loved this book since I first read it. I taught it to a number of classes and almost without exception they not only loved it but loved it because it contained the elements and layers that you so clearly expound. An excellent review that reveals the depths of what I regard as an important novel for young adults and not so young ones.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I’m still trying to understand why this is such a powerful YA novel, Jeanne, but I appreciate why your children may have responded positively to it, especially given that they’re nearer the target age than I am!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. earthbalm

    Went to the cinema with the whole of Key Stage 2 when this first came out as a film. Later, read the book. Unusually, I found the book and the film equals. Very enjoyable indeed!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I was wondering how well the film stood up compared with the book, Dale, particularly as the same writer was involved in both, so what you say reassures me. Similarly, William Goldman did the screenplay as well as the novel for The Princess Bride and each stands on its own merits. Definitely going to keep an eye out for the film now!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: Square pegs — Calmgrove – Earth Balm Creative

  5. So glad you found this book, Chris. Sachar’s tale is sooo good (it won the Newbery for 1999). Everything you say is spot on, but I want to point out how well Sachar gets the landscape (as in your photo). The heat, the dust, the lizards, the insects — even the sounds of screen doors, overhead fans, and humming fridges full of soda pop. And what a perfect villain (Sigourney Weaver is perfect as The Warden)!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, so much one could say about this book! It definitely conjured that landscape — one I’ve had to imagine, never having experienced anything remotely close to a desert — and those specifically North American features (fridges filled with cold drinks, screen doors) that I only know from the screen. In Hong Kong it was more a humid heat, though we had the insects, especially cockroaches and mosquitoes.

      As key grip our son Cameron has worked on three seasons now of TV show Doc Martin with Martin Clunes, and was really chuffed when Sigourney made guest appearances, earning his respect for her sense of humour!

      Liked by 1 person

Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.