Both real and magical

Newgale beach, Pembrokeshire

Cath Barton: The Plankton Collector
New Welsh Rarebyte 2018

Winner of a New Welsh Writing Award for 2017 in the novella category, The Plankton Collector is one of those dreamlike pieces that at odd moments rises unbidden to the surface of this reader’s thoughts like a bubble from unknown depths. To describe it as magic realism is not the whole story, yet the narrative does in fact drift like a leaf on a pond from one magical moment to another before catching on the rocks of reality, the reality of authentic lives lived with pain and sorrow and maybe, ultimately, hope.

We begin at the seaside with a beautiful piece of nature writing, as lyrical, say, as anything Charles Kingsley wrote in Glaucus, or the Wonders of the Shore. Here we meet the Plankton Collector himself, a shapeshifter who sifts sand and shells for living creatures, ultimately to show them how they might fit into the mysterious patterns of existence.

Lest the prologue, all told in the historic present, should appear too airy-fairy we may note that it is titled ‘In the Beginning’—as with Genesis we shall find that all is not perfect in the garden, that there’s a worm in the bud which will upset a family’s idyll for some time to come. The novella gropes towards a resolution that at times seems just out of our grasp.

We meet the family—David, Rose and their three children, Edgar, Bunny and Mary. We see from separate points of view how a death affects each surviving family member in turn, causing the Plankton Collector to appear in succession in different guises—as gardener, as uncle, as lover, as kindly Mr Smith. Who is he?

This man is a little like the Pied Piper of Hamelin, or Svengali, or Dr Who, and yet he is none of these. He sings, but he does not hypnotise, neither does he offer time travel, at least not to other galaxies. Inside our own world he is certainly a traveller. Think of this: when you last walked through the centre of your town, you might well have passed him…

What he does is offer balm for the spirits of those he sees suffering from life’s hard knocks. He does it quietly, with compassion, and so subtly that no-one doubts him—and even though they may be initially puzzled over his appearance into their lives, acquaintance soon shades into acceptance. As each individual’s hurts and anxieties are laid bare George, or Mr Smith, or Colin is there to soothe and ease them away.

He’s not all-powerful, the Plankton Collector, but he is indubitably a magician. His modus operandi includes visits to the seaside, the collecting of shells, the making of shell pictures. The liminal aspects of sea meeting shore and sky, and the sea creatures that have a function after death, together provide therapy and initiate a healing process.

While the writing becomes a little more prosaic (and marginally pedestrian) towards the end of the novella, its underlying lyricism and deep sympathy for the fragile members of this family—parents and children alike—are the qualities that linger in the mind. In all this The Plankton Collector combines powerfully the lightness of illusion with a tangible realism that we recognise (and may even have ourselves experienced). A powerful debut work.

I should add that Cath Barton is an acquaintance but that I’ve tried to give an honest review of this work. In preparation for March’s Wales Readathon aka Dewithon19 (hosted by Paula at Book Jotter) I hope to be reading a couple more writings connected with Wales, of which this is the first for this year.

15 thoughts on “Both real and magical

  1. Pingback: Both real and magical — Calmgrove – Earth Balm Creative

  2. earthbalm

    I found this as part of an Amazon review: “From the very first sentence, it’s like being able to crawl into the lap of your grandmother or grandfather in a rocking chair. There’s a flow to the language which is like breathing in and out, or rocking gently in a boat, and then the characters are drawn with such subtlety, honesty, and compassion.” Review posted by H. Hewett.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This one also intrigues me. You always make me want to read that which you do. This title goes to my list of books to consider when I get to add new ones. (Maybe a treat in a few months, once I have read a few of the ones I have committed to this year).

    Liked by 2 people

      1. I see. It’s still worthy to me. (We are talking about new authors, I think it’s our readers responsibility to buy and read their books). But I may have to wait. This year I am trying to be just a tad more patient and organized. I am writing possible titles for a few months from now. I will tell you at that time if I am getting this and your former student’s debut title.

        Liked by 2 people

        1. I agree about encouraging new authors, Silvia, though I know I shall still mostly be reading established authors, whether contemporary or classic. I look forward to reading your reactions to these two authors, or indeed any others, in the coming months!

          Liked by 2 people

  4. Pingback: Giving new authors a chance – Silvia Cachia

  5. Pingback: Winding up the Week #53 – Book Jotter

Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.