Heart and soul

Philip Pullman: Clockwork, or All Wound Up
Illustrated by Peter Bailey
Corgi Yearling Books 2004 (1996)

Delicious fun is how best to describe this tale within tales. Here we find Pullman telling a story, in which a storyteller tells a story, out of which frame a character steps into life. Like an old-fashioned clock the mechanism of Pullman’s fairytale fantasy gets wound up and “no matter how much the characters would like to change their fate, they can’t.” And by story’s end we find out exactly how the characters all, literally, “wound up”.

This story is set one winter’s evening in a German town called Glockenheim (“home of the bells”). Glockenheim has a great clock overseen by the town’s clockmaker Herr Ringelmann (“ringing man”), whose apprentice Karl is supposed to be installing a mechanical figure for the clock on the morrow. On the eve of the installation worthies and others gather in a tavern to hear the traditional ghost story told by Fritz the local author. Unfortunately neither apprentice nor writer has completed his creation. Can lowly serving girl Gretl provide the key to completing the tale?

Clockwork is a superb novelette, a literary fairytale with a Gothick flavour in the tradition of The King of the Golden River and Pinocchio. With working automata — one of which becomes human — prohibitions, magic words, suspense, compassion, a sinister “philosopher of the night”, cowardly townsfolk, moral decisions to make and, of course, a royal family, Clockwork has the toolbox of motifs and situations to satisfy pretty much all one’s expectations. Add to that appealing illustrations by Peter Bailey and authorial asides in the form of text boxes (full of informative details and improving advice) and this is a book with very broad appeal, from pre-teens who like shivers down their backs to adults who appreciate intertextuality, metafictional devices lightly done and quiet punning.

This adult, then, liked the allusions to Greek mythology: Talos was the brazen robot in Jason and the Argonauts who may be referenced by the mechanical knight with the sword, who menaces any speaker who utters one specific word. The single way to halt this murderous approach is similar to that used by Medea to nullify Talos — by chanting a spell. Further, the Dr Kalmenius who creates these quasi-living automata is like Victor Frankenstein, but he also resembles Geppetto, who carves the puppet Pinocchio out of wood. The only thing Kalmenius cannot do is to fashion a living heart, one that can drive his creations for longer than a few years; there’s only one way that he knows of, and he’s not the person to accomplish that.

Thus Clockwork is about creation, and the distinction between manufacturing and engendering, between the inanimate made animate for a while, and true animation which involves the anima or soul. This is the heart of the novelette, both literally and quintessentially. But Pullman wraps this all up with a rattling good narrative, a winter’s tale that displays mock solemnity without wearing its heart on its sleeve. To find that heart you have to put in just a little effort.

Cardiff Castle, a Victorian fantasy built round a historic core (clock tower far left)

Clockwork is another post loosely themed with Lory’s blog The Emerald City Book Review Witch Week focus ‘Dreams of Arthur’. After all, it’s a ghost story with a knight in it …

Some images from The Clockwork Moth’s production of Clockwork as a shadow puppet play can be seen here.

Prince Florian in The Clockwork Moth‘s shadow play production of Clockwork (http://www.theclockworkmoth.com/past-projectsgallery/philip-pullmans-clockwork-2/)

12 thoughts on “Heart and soul

    1. Ah, and I thought I might get away without explaining it! I imagined that Gretl would be the one with heart — she takes it on herself to look after another out of compassion — while the looked-after one, the ‘inanimate’ individual, gains the ‘soul’. I’d give too much of the game away if I was more specific, but it all turns on a phrase about giving and receiving …

      Liked by 2 people

  1. earthbalm

    Thanks for the post Chris. This is one of my two favourite children’s ‘novelettes’ of the last 20 or so years. Philip Pullman’s “The Firework Maker’s Daughter” is the other. There is some lovely wordplay and many creative plot twists in these works, the characters are engaging and the illustrations (as you mention) really do enhance the reading experience. Pullman’s influences are many but, I think, he has a style all his own.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve had The Firework Maker’s Daughter recommended to me and also one about a scarecrow, but this came up first! Puns and plot twists and people and pictures — all perfect. 🙂

      Anyway, I’d got this a little while ago as preparation for La Belle Sauvage which I’m finding both gripping and engaging so far. Trying to eke it out, but with little success …

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Annabel (gaskella)

    I blogged about Clockwork a couple of week ago too… having discovered it is Pullman’s favourite of his books.It is a lovely novella, very Hoffmannesque.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Hoffmanesque — a perfect description! (I think Penguin do a collected edition of his Tales, though I haven’t chased it up yet.) I’ll find your review now. I didn’t know this was Pullman’s favourite; its mood reminded me of his Count Karlstein title, novelised from a school play he’d written.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. earthbalm

    The Scarecrow and His Servant… an entertaining, if slightly surreal book (I had a hardcover version), that I read to a year 3/4 class then ‘raffled off’ to a class member. I’d treat yourself to a read of The Firework Maker’s Daughter. Would you like my hardcover copy of Rosemary Sutcliff’s Arthurian Sword at Sunset? I could drop it up to your daughter! I need to clear out quite a few of my books as my son’s book collection continues to grow exponentially.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. TFMD it is then! Ooh, if I had a hb copy of the Sutcliff I’d be encouraged to read it again instead of the falling-apart pb I’ve got now languishing upstairs — yes please, Dale!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Great review, Chris. I read half-way through and stopped to see if I can find the book. Sadly, my library only carries a few of Pulman’s book, but Amazon has two used for sale. One now has my name on it. Thank you again for giving us book addicts yet another must read.

    Liked by 1 person

Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.