A celebration of true magic


This is a repost of a review first published 26th March 2014
and republished here to mark #MarchMagics and #DWJMarch,
a celebration of all things Diana Wynne Jones and Terry Pratchett

Diana Wynne Jones The Islands of Chaldea
completed by Ursula Jones
HarperCollins Children’s Books 2014

Fantasy writer Diana Wynne Jones would have been 80 this year. Since her death on March 26th 2011 some fans have designated March as Diana Wynne Jones Month — by reading, reviewing and discussing her novels they felt that this would be “a way to turn mourning to celebration on the anniversary of Diana’s death”. The third #dwjmonth (also tagged #dwjmarch) is being observed as I write [March 2014].

This year was extra special: her final novel, completed by her sister Ursula (an author in her own right), was published just in time for a celebration of the woman and her work. As a result of suggesting — rather cheekily, I thought — that I was Diana’s “greatest fan”, I was lucky enough to win one of ten copies offered in a competition by her British publishers. As always with posthumous novels the worry is, will this work be up to her usual standard, or will disappointment cloud the reputation that she painstakingly established for herself?

We find ourselves in on an alternate Earth, one of the author’s Related Worlds which are similar to but not the same as our own, chiefly because magic is always prevalent. The Islands of Chaldea (the real Mesopotamian polity of Chaldea was famed for its magicians) are Skarr, Bernica, Gallis and Logra, loosely based on Scotland, Ireland, Wales and England. The four countries, as well as being separated from each other by water, are further divided by a magical barrier that has for some years closed Logra off from the other three islands. On Skarr lives Aileen, a potential young Wise Woman who despairs of inheriting the talents that she is supposed to develop. Unexpectedly she is sent, with her Aunt Beck, idle princeling Ivar and servant Ogo, on a journey to Logra via Bernica and Gallis, to help resolve the situation and to fulfil a prophecy. We sense the classic premise of the lowliest achieving greatness through discovering and using innate gifts and skills.

Aileen, with green eyes and hair “the colour of toffee”, is also the narrator, diminutive in stature but growing in maturity. She describes how she is sent with some odd companions and a disreputable crew to achieve an ill-defined quest, in which barriers galore — and not just the magical one — are placed in the way of success. First they arrive on the tiny island called Lone, where they encounter a rather peculiar creature. Next, they cross over to Bernica where they acquire another companion and another creature, as green as our own Emerald Isle is supposed to be. (There’s an episode here involving humans turned into donkeys that recalls Petronius, Shakespeare, Kingsley and Collodi, who also riff on the theme.) They somehow get to Gallis where more companions join them, and yet another creature puts in an appearance. Then they have to find a way to surmount that final obstacle to reach Logra where, if the pattern holds, we must expect another beast to present another crucial piece of the puzzle. Will solutions be forthcoming?

Such a bald outline in no way does justice to the author’s narrative skill, especially in her ability to recapture a young person’s tone in relating a story. In addition, for those in the know, there is the delight of discovering how much she has drawn in the myth, legend and folklore of the British Isles to almost, dare one say it, make a political statement about individual cultures coexisting within shared traditions. And, in answer to the common question she got asked — “Where do you get your ideas from?” — her usual inventiveness is displayed in the way, magpie-like, she has picked up various shiny objects to line the nest of her story.

Let’s start with the animals. The red winged lizard that appears in this story is associated with Gallis, not surprising as the emblem of Wales is a dragon. Less obvious is the talking green parrot that Aileen and her companions discover in Bernica (this name derived, of course, from an old name for Ireland). A green bird would be appropriate for Ireland, but why has the author hit on a non-native bird? Perhaps the legendary island called Hy Brasil to the west of Ireland suggested to her the modern country of Brazil, through which flows the Amazon; and in its jungles are the medium-sized green birds, good at imitating speech, called Amazon parrots.

The third of the four animals is a large cat, no ordinary beast this but one which can disappear at will, rather like the Cheshire Cat. With its ‘long legs [and] small head’ I wonder if a European lynx is meant rather than the Scottish wildcat, even though Aileen hails from the Chaldean equivalent of Scotland. The lynx apparently survived in Britain into the Dark Ages, and may  have furnished a basis for the lions encountered in Arthurian legends as the Welsh Cath Palug (“clawing cat”) and the chapulu of French Alpine lore. I think what confirms this for me is Aileen’s nickname for the cat, Plug-Ugly. The Land of Lone where Plug-Ugly is found could represent the Isle of Man, but Jones has also woven in strands from folktales about the sunken land of Cantre’r Gwaelod, the Welsh Lowland Hundred that disappeared in Cardigan Bay as the result of human error.

And the fourth animal? Surely Diana drew on the traditional symbols of the four evangelists for inspiration here, coming up with the bull, symbol of St Luke, to represent Logra. (The parrot derives from St John’s eagle and the cat from St Mark’s winged lion; only the dragon deviates from St Matthew’s man, though both of course have wings. Ultimately the four creatures derive from the cherubim who according to Ezekiel supported God’s throne, appearing as man, lion, ox and eagle.)

Helpful Companions are the staple of traditional fairytales, where they aid the hero or heroine in accomplishing impossible tasks. Often they collectively form a group of seven, as here, and without them Aileen wouldn’t be able to achieve her quest. For example, Aileen’s Aunt Beck has the gift of visions; a wonderful character who must surely have been drawn from life, she unfortunately suffers from what appears to be a stroke — though of course, this being a literary fairytale, this affliction is the traditional ‘fairy stroke’, the result of a malevolent spell, rather than the more lasting physical ailment that we know by the name. Meanwhile the Bernican monk called Finn is the owner of the wonderful parrot which gives more appropriate advice than is usual for these talking birds. Riannan from Gallis has the ability to sing spells, rather like her counterpart in Welsh tales who converses with birds, while her brother Rees infuses mechanical inventions with magic. And Ivar and Ogo have their own significant roles to play too.

Fairytales have their villains, and here the baddie is someone whose name aptly includes a Germanic element which means ‘rule’ or ‘power’. We must be very grateful to Ursula Jones for finding a way to successfully resolve the very complex plot from a clue presented early on in Diana’s incomplete manuscript. Ursula doesn’t say what this clue is but I suspect it’s the handing over of a purse, supposedly “for expenses” but of course nothing of the kind. I haven’t yet spotted where the transition to a different author is, though I sense a change in style and pace around Chapter Fourteen. What is definitely Diana’s contribution, however, is the introduction of a hot-air balloon into the plot. Bristol, where she lived, is host of a spectacular International Balloon Fiesta every summer, and she would have been very familiar with the sight of Montgolfier balloons floating across the river Avon and over Clifton.

The Islands of Chaldea is a love-letter to Britain, a hymn to hope and a celebration of true magic, which is the life of the imagination. While fans may regret her passing, whether as friend or author, this final novel is a fitting addition to the canon and one to be grateful for now that it has been completed in style.

Finally, I’d like here to report on a coincidence, if coincidence it is. Diana Wynne Jones and I shared a regular correspondent, the late Bill Russell. Bill, a professor emeritus of sociology, was president of the Pendragon Society, an Arthurian group for which I edited the journal. In spring 2005 I published an article I’d put together called ‘A Concise Arthurian Bestiary’ listing a number of creatures associated with Arthurian legends and folklore, including cat, dragon and parrot. Now Bill was in the habit of sending some of his complimentary copies of Pendragon to other correspondents, and as I’d included his review of Diana’s Hexwood in the same issue I suspect there’s every chance that he’d sent a copy of this to her. It’s distantly possible that her choice of featured animals in The Islands of Chaldea was influenced or at least confirmed by the mention of cat, dragon and parrot in the bestiary article – though admittedly more likely that Diana was already familiar with their associations.

The four evangelists, the Book of Kells (Wikipedia Commons)
The four evangelists, the Book of Kells (Wikipedia Commons)

16 thoughts on “A celebration of true magic

  1. A very thoughtful review – much more erudite than mine! I thought there was definitely a Breton influence in Jones’ conception of Gallis, as well as Wales. I did not know about the Balloon Fiesta – that sounds fabulous!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re very probably right about the Breton — there were a couple of phrases towards the end that looked vaguely Welsh but weren’t so could’ve been Breton. However, the shapes of the islands were definitely distorted versions of the British Isles, with Snowdonia, the Lleyn peninsula, Pembrokeshire and Tonypandy slyly alluded to in the depiction of Gallis. Howevet we have no way of knowing if the map was based on Diana’s own sketch or was made up by the artist! (Incidentally, the scale surrounding the chart makes no sense, did you notice?)

      Thank you for the ‘erudite’ label — ‘obsessive’ might be more accurate! Incidentally, before moving to West Wales I lived in Bristol, and watched the Balloon Fiesta grow from half a dozen enthusiasts having a mass lift-off in the early 70s grow to reputedly the largest of its kind in Europe. A truly magificent sight, especially watching them, when the wind direction is right, sailing virtually past your window!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Lory @ Emerald City Book Review

    Thank you for these very illuminating notes, from the reference to the Four Creatures to the balloon festival! I must read this again soon with new eyes.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. earthbalm

    Thanks for this post. This was a book I enjoyed reading though I never did spot the point where Ursula took over the writing. I’ve read that once you know, you’ll see the join but I don’t know and therefore, I can’t. I’m looking forward to more Diana Wynne Jones posts.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I’ve neglected her for a while, haven’t I. I’ve read pretty much all her novels, though not the pre-teen books, and I know there are several short stories I’m unfamiliar with. So I’ll get on with some reviews after I’ve done a bit of rereading. Anyway, glad you enjoyed the repost! I suppose I should read this again to see if my hunch about the join was correct or even likely …

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: Chaldea – A change is coming…

  5. I have not read this book, but your post is compelling. As a Medieval history major, seeing the photos of the four evangelists sure bring back memories of going through all those manuscripts 🙂 Now I am intrigued

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So nostalgia is what it used to be! I love spotting iconography of the four evangelists on church tympanums, on stained glass windows and so on — such variety in interpretations and depictions!


  6. So, indirectly, you may well have contributed to the dramatis personae! Far more likely than that she got the parrot from Enid Blyton.
    It seems that as competent a job was done in the completion as is to be found with Elgar’s unfinished symphony.
    *stubbornly* I still say she features alternative and not alternate worlds!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think she was dismissive of Enid Blyton, but I may have misremembered that! Can’t comment on Elgar’s unfinished, but the resolution here is as satisfying as might be hoped.

      I too prefer the term ‘alternative world’ — ‘alternate’ makes it sound as though they swap from one world to another, a bit like alternating current — but that seems to be the accepted term, and who am I to fight against loose phraseology? We are as lone voices in the wilderness …


  7. Oh I definitely need to reread Islands now. I, too, was looking for the shift, but I couldn’t catch it. “Love-letter to Britain” is very apt, and I wish I could elaborate on my reactions more, only my youngest has gotten up and is sitting on one of my arms. But I am so very glad you sent me this–I didn’t know March was a celebrate DWJ month! I’ve been planning a series for 2018 on studying books’ first chapters for their world-building, and wanted to visit a DWJ book I hadn’t analyzed yet. Now I know which month to do it. 🙂

    Thank you again for reaching out. I’m always so excited to meet someone else who appreciates her and all her work. Some days I feel like the only grown-up in all of Wisconsin who knows her books exist…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hopefully, even if no adults, there’ll be some Wisconsin kids who are into her stuff (and not just Howl’s Moving Castle)! Maybe your youngest likes her books too?

      That series on opening sentences soundsright up my street, I’m so looking forward with anticipation for that 🙂

      Anyway, glad this fired you up, so pleased to find another DWJ fan who looks beyond the superficialities!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. LOL! Yes! It does, indeed! I feel like I’ll be spending Christmas Break digging through your archives for more reviews and things. 😉 Alas, my kids are not big on fantasy. My eldest, 7, is very much a scientist. “Is that real? No? Oh.” (eyes go elsewhere back to her book on the periodic table of elements) But my sons, both 5, are promising in their love of imagination and creativity.
        Ah, I’m not fair to my daughter. She’s creative too, but in her way–she loves inventing things and designing things with Legos. Bo and I are trying to approach her with a cycle of fiction and nonfiction to try and find where her attention spikes. It’s a work in progress. 🙂


Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.