Three collections, three mini-reviews

Life-size (?) dragon outside bedroom window, Miskin Manor, Cardiff

Here is a trio of mini-reviews of collections of short stories, novels and a novella. The idea is to whet your appetite for fuller reviews which I am planning over the months ahead of individual books in the two quartets focused on Earthsea and on Sally Lockheart, as well as the novella in Unexpected Magic.

Ursula Le Guin The Earthsea Quartet:
A Wizard of Earthsea, The Tombs of Atuan, The Farthest Shore, Tehanu

Puffin Books 1993 (1990)

When I first read The Wizard of Earthsea I could almost believe in magic, so credible was the description of Ged’s emerging talents. Years later, magic of a different kind was uppermost in my second reading of the trilogy (along with Tehanu and the two other sequels). This magic was to do with sympathetic characterisation and with the creation of credible imaginary cultures and worlds as much as with hope and tragedy, with human triumphs and failings, with empathy and enmity. A relatively recent reading of The Chronicles of Narnia impressed me so much with the degree that Le Guin has surpassed Lewis in her depiction of a humanistic as well as humane alternative universe; superficially there are some similarities (many common to much fantasy, such as magic, maps and mythical animals) but the tone and the richness and the “rightness” of her creation is what sets it apart from Lewis’ world: if Narnia is a tapestry then Earthsea is a working model of a reality. This sequence is I’m sure one of those works that reveals further treasures with each successive reading.

Diana Wynne Jones Unexpected Magic:
Collected Stories
Eos 2006 (2004)

The title is so apt in both senses, in that in DWJ’s worlds anything can happen (and usually does) plus that for the reader the stories can (and do) provide the magic that may be missing in their own more prosaic world. The stories are a little uneven, as they are aimed at different audiences (those who like whimsy, or cats, or were once in a bygone age bemused by word processors). The novella, Everard’s Ride, for me was misplaced in this collection: first, its additional length made the paperback physically awkward to handle and, second, its setting and plot convolutions were a mismatch with the unidirectional flow of the other tales; it should really remain separately published as standing on its own merits. That all said, my favourites were the novella and the autobiographical story, ‘The Girl Jones’, which opened the collection.

Philip Pullman Sally Lockhart Mystery Collection:
The Shadow in the North, The Ruby in the Smoke, The Tin Princess, The Tiger in the Well

Scholastic 2010

With its uniform editions of Philip Pullman’s Sally Lockhart quartet, this box set features as covers pictures from the faithful BBC TV adaptations of the first two titles as part of an planned tie-in. Pullman has captured exactly a mix of late Victorian fiction styles with elements of Dickens, Wilkie Collins, Conan Doyle, Jules Verne and penny dreadfuls, spiced up with a little bit of Bram Stoker. The first three novels are fantastic reads, taking place as they do in a largely believable Victorian world, but the last novel, while no less exciting, is slightly let down by its Ruritanian setting in a fictional mid-European country.

4 thoughts on “Three collections, three mini-reviews

    1. When I first read it it just seemed an unnecessary add-on to the earlier trio, and much less credible for being set in a blatantly imaginary country. My opinion might possibly change after a re-read, Nikki — I’ll endeavour to be positive anyway!


  1. LeGuin, of course, beats everyone at world building (with the possible exception of Tolkien). I started *The Tin Princess* a couple of years ago but wasn’t drawn in. I’m happy to learn I wasn’t wrong. As for Ruritanian worlds, it’s hard to beat the eponym, but George Barr McCutcheon’s Graustark series comes close.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Your comment about Le Guin’s worldbuilding reminds me that I’ve got some notes on her Orsinian Tales somewhere to work into a review, and her Changing Planes to finish, which I stalled on a year or so ago (which I’ve just realised is ideal for the Reading Challenge’s ‘book started but never finished’!). Thanks too for the new author recommendation, Lizzie — one to bear in mind.


Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.