No justice in Giudecca?

Donna Leon Uniform Justice Arrow 2004

Donna Leon’s Commissario Brunetti has been compared to Camilleri’s Commissario Montalbano so many times that I felt I had to at least sample one of the titles in her series, and I’m glad I did. In Uniform Justice Brunetti is a world-weary detective investigating an apparent suicide at a cadet school run on military lines on the Venetian island of Giudecca. I was intrigued immediately, as I remember seeing the island from the windows of our overnight hotel opposite. Especially when it was blotted out by a passing cruise ship.

World-weary detectives are two-a-penny in crime fiction, especially when they are saddled with unsympathetic superiors as Brunetti is, and Venice is such an obvious setting that we could be forgiven for thinking that this is bound to be a run-of-the-mill mystery. Well, we would be wrong. This is very much a character-driven novel, especially where the Commissario and his long-suffering but forbearing wife are concerned, that you can’t help feeling that at times the investigation plays second fiddle to their relationship. Almost as interesting an individual is Signorina Elettra, Brunetti’s … well, what to call her? Secretary? Backroom staff? Dogsbody?

Uniform Justice concerns a crime which has ramifications in the worlds of the military and in political corruption, a heady and dangerous brew which Brunetti has to beware of drinking too much of. His liberal conscience is forced to consider compromises as he struggles towards the truth of what happened in a cadet school as staff, students and victim’s parents throw up a wall of silence. We can see the inevitable coming, and it is a weight on the soul of the sensitive investigator.

Reviews by Brunetti aficionados suggest this novel is not one of the best of the series, but I still found it haunting, thought-provoking, beautiful and well-written, and streets ahead of (or in a Venetian context, canals apart from) some mysteries I have recently read.

Review first published August 2012, and slightly revised. I have a couple more Inspector Brunetti novels, certainly overdue a read and then review


5 thoughts on “No justice in Giudecca?

  1. There now. We have been looking for a decent audiobook of just this calibre – we play them as we are going to sleep – and this sounds perfect. I wonder if this exists in audiobook? Off to investigate.


  2. Great post, and useful comments here, as I was just thinking how much I would like to read this – a friend of mine recommended Donna Leon a couple of years back – but also how it is still at the bottom of a long ‘to read’ list, but I might manage to shoehorn it in as an audiobook.


    1. Have a browse through the several titles in the series first to get a flavour — you might even find a different title you prefer to begin with as this is by no means the first of the sequence, though as far as I can work out each one can be read on its own without loss of context.


Do leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.